So To Speak: Why Everyone Is Talking About an Anti-Dynasty Law Again

By Sonia P. Soto

Calls for an anti-dynasty law are back in the spotlight. Not because an election is near—but because recent political developments have once again put powerful families at the center of national debate. 

Public frustration over corruption, accountability, and concentration of power has reignited an old question: Are political dynasties the problem—or the kind of power our system still lets them hold? Some people say reopening this issue distracts from more urgent work: prosecuting corrupt officials and recovering stolen public money. 

Fair point. Accountability cannot wait. But ignoring the dynasty question won’t help either. These renewed calls are not really about names. They reflect anxiety about a political system where influence lasts too long, power spreads too wide, and consequences too often fail to arrive.

Kaya sasali ako sa diskusyong ito—hindi para makisabay sa ingay, kundi para tanungin kung ano ba talaga ang ugat ng problema.

Why surnames still matter here

In an ideal democracy, your last name shouldn’t shape your political future. In the Philippines, it often does. A familiar political name can mean:

 • instant campaign machinery,

 • deep local networks,

 • easier access to permits, projects, and aid,

 • and influence over enforcement.

So no—it’s not accurate to say surnames don’t matter. Sa Pilipinas, ang apelyido ay hindi lang pangalan—madalas, ito ang susi. But stopping there is too easy.

Dynasties don’t start the fire—they grow because of it

Political dynasties expand when three things collide:

Weak enforcement

We have laws and watchdogs, but cases stall, investigations drag, and penalties often don’t land.

May batas, pero walang bagsik. 

Poverty and dependency

When people struggle to survive, politics becomes less about platforms and more about who can actually help today.

Kapag gutom ang sikmura, mahina ang boses ng prinsipyo.

Winner-take-all local power

Local officials control permits, jobs, relief goods, and projects. When one family dominates, challengers face steep odds.

Kung iisa ang may hawak ng gripo, natural na doon pipila ang lahat.

In this setting, surnames don’t just label candidates. They organize power.

Poverty and dynasties: the uncomfortable link

Philippine research consistently shows that political dynasties are most common where poverty is deepest.

That doesn’t prove simple cause and effect. The relationship goes both ways. Poverty strengthens patronage—and entrenched power can slow reform.

One takeaway is hard to ignore:

Where life is hardest, political power holds on the tightest.

Are all dynasties bad?

No.

Some political families deliver continuity and long-term programs. In towns with limited capacity, that stability can matter.

But the real issue isn’t family participation.

It’s what happens when one group can:

 • dominate local government,

 • weaken oversight,

 • influence enforcement, and

 • survive scandal without consequences.

At that point, elections alone aren’t enough.

Hindi na ito pamumuno. Pamamayani na ito.

Why an anti-dynasty law won’t solve everything

The Constitution calls for regulating political dynasties, but decades later, the enabling law still hasn’t passed.

Even if one finally does, it won’t magically end patronage. In weak systems, bans often lead to proxies—relatives, allies, and political stand-ins.

Palit-apelyido, pareho pa rin ang galaw.

Change the faces.

The system stays.

The boundary that actually matters

Surnames must never grant immunity.

Patronage is human.

Nepotism depends on context.

Dynasties become dangerous only when enforcement disappears.

Connections may open doors.

They should never shield anyone from the law.

Saying “surnames don’t matter” is naïve.

Saying “surnames are the whole problem” is lazy.

The tougher truth is this:

In the Philippines, surnames matter because rules still don’t bite hard enough.

Until institutions enforce the law equally—no matter how powerful the family—the calls for an anti-dynasty law will keep coming back.

At habang ganoon, ang tunay na nananalo ay hindi serbisyo—kundi impunity. #